So I went through the list one by one and gave each gift a BUY, a MAYBE or a SKIP. Final count on the 72 I rated on camera: 46 buys, 21 maybes and only 5 skips.
Get all 100 in one free PDF
My free guide has every gift on the list, my verdict on each one, my cheaper swaps and the Home & Garden and Toys picks I didn't get to in the video, all with shoppable links.
Get the Free PDF
My favorite BUYS
Beauty
Fashion
Accessories
Home and tech
The 5 I'd skip
- Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser. Not terrible, but I've found cleansers I like better. My pick instead: Philosophy Purity Made Simple.
- Face sculpting gua sha brush. The results are temporary. The juice isn't worth the squeeze.
- Steve Madden split-toe ballet flat. That style just isn't for me.
- Away Signature Companion Bag. It's pricey, and I couldn't see what makes it special.
- Athleta Salutation Stash Legging. Great sizes and lengths, but leggings aren't my thing.
What I learned from the list
The best gifts on Google's list weren't the viral ones. They were the simple, useful things someone will actually use: a good carry-on, packing cubes, a robot vacuum, classic pearls. If you're not sure, choose useful over trendy.
Shop my picks
Everything I said yes to is in my gift guides on LTK. Prefer it all in one place? Grab the free PDF.
Google's list reflects search trends, not product testing. Prices change often, especially around Black Friday.
Which gift would YOU skip that I said buy? Tell me in the comments on the video.